Business | Managing change

Managing Change: Navigating the Tides of Business Strategy

Hello future Business leaders! Welcome to a chapter that is absolutely crucial for understanding business decisions and strategy: Managing Change.

Why is this chapter so important? Because planning a brilliant strategy is only half the battle. The other half is actually implementing it—and implementation almost always requires change. Whether it's adopting new technology or shifting your entire business model, if change isn't managed well, even the best strategies will fail.

Don't worry if this seems tricky at first. We are going to break down how businesses adapt, why people resist, and use famous models to help you understand how successful change happens!

---

1. Understanding the Need for Change

Change is constant in the business world. For a business strategy to be successful, it must react to forces for change. These forces can be internal (coming from inside the organisation) or external (coming from the wider world).

External Forces Driving Change

These are factors outside the business’s direct control. Think of the PESTLE framework here!

• Technological Change: The rapid evolution of tech forces businesses to upgrade systems, adopt AI, or move sales online. (Example: Netflix replacing Blockbuster, or traditional retailers needing e-commerce platforms.)
• Competitive Pressure: Rivals launching better products, lowering prices, or finding more efficient processes compels you to change your own operations.
• Economic Shifts: Changes in interest rates, inflation, or disposable income force strategies to adapt (e.g., shifting production overseas due to rising domestic costs).
• Social/Demographic Changes: Changing customer tastes, ethical demands (sustainability), or shifts in workforce demographics.

Internal Forces Driving Change

These forces originate within the company, often due to strategic decisions or performance issues.

• New Leadership or Ownership: A new CEO often means a new strategic direction, requiring widespread operational change.
• New Objectives or Strategy: A decision to enter a new market or switch to a high-cost/high-quality strategy demands changes in training, resources, and culture.
• Poor Performance: Failing to meet targets forces the business to radically restructure or downsize.

Key Takeaway: Businesses must constantly monitor their environment. Successful strategic decisions are those that anticipate and manage these changes effectively.

2. Types of Change

We can classify change based on how quickly or dramatically it occurs. This helps management decide how much preparation is needed.

1. Incremental Change

• This is gradual, small-scale, continuous change.
• It focuses on improving existing processes, systems, and efficiency.
• Analogy: Incremental change is like slowly updating the software on your phone with small patches and fixes.

2. Disruptive (or Radical) Change

• This is rapid, fundamental change that often transforms the industry or the business structure entirely.
• It usually results from a new, breakthrough innovation or technology.
• Analogy: Disruptive change is like switching from using a landline phone to a smartphone—the entire way you communicate changes.

3. Resistance to Change

One of the biggest hurdles in strategic implementation is resistance—the refusal of employees or stakeholders to cooperate with the proposed changes.

Understanding why people resist is the first step to overcoming it.

Common Causes of Resistance

• Self-Interest: Individuals may feel they will lose something valuable, such as their job security, status, or pay.
• Fear of the Unknown: People prefer the familiar, even if it’s inefficient. The change presents uncertainty, which can be paralyzing. (Example: Employees may resist a new IT system because they worry they won't be able to learn it.)
• Misunderstanding: Sometimes, employees simply don’t understand the purpose of the change or believe management is wrong. If they don't see the need for urgency, they won't comply.
• Inertia or Habit: People are comfortable doing things the way they always have. Breaking established habits requires effort.

Memory Aid: FIIS (A simple way to remember four common causes)

Fear of the unknown
Interest (Self-interest)
Inertia (Habit)
Security (Threats to job security)

---

4. Models for Managing Change

To successfully implement a strategic change and overcome resistance, businesses often use structured models. The two most commonly studied models are Kurt Lewin’s and John Kotter’s.

4.1. Lewin’s Three-Step Model (Unfreeze-Change-Refreeze)

Kurt Lewin saw change like melting and reshaping an ice cube. You can’t just change the shape of ice instantly; you must prepare it first.

Step 1: Unfreeze

• Goal: Preparing the organisation for change and creating a sense of urgency.
• Action: Management must clearly demonstrate why the status quo (the current way of doing things) is unacceptable or dangerous. This involves challenging existing beliefs and assumptions.
• Example: Presenting data that shows the company is losing market share because competitors have better technology.

Step 2: Change (Transition)

• Goal: Implementing the new processes, structure, or strategy.
• Action: Providing training, resources, new systems, and strong leadership support. Communication is vital during this messy, often confusing stage.

Step 3: Refreeze

• Goal: Stabilising the organisation and embedding the new changes so they become the new normal.
• Action: Updating policies, adjusting reward systems, and celebrating successes to ensure the changes stick and the organisation does not revert to old habits.

4.2. Kotter’s Eight-Step Change Model

John Kotter, a leading expert on leadership, developed a more detailed, sequential model focusing heavily on the role of leadership and communication in managing large-scale strategic change.

This model is particularly useful for managing disruptive change.

1. Establish a Sense of Urgency: Examine the market and competitive realities, and convince people that immediate action is necessary (similar to Lewin's 'Unfreeze').
2. Form a Powerful Guiding Coalition: Put together a team of influential leaders and managers from across the business who will champion the change.
3. Create a Vision for Change: Develop a clear, simple, and inspiring vision and strategy to direct the change effort. (What does the future look like?)
4. Communicate the Vision: Use every possible channel to constantly communicate the new vision. This needs to be done frequently and by example.
5. Empower Others to Act: Remove obstacles, structures, and policies that undermine the new vision. Encourage risk-taking and non-traditional ideas.
6. Plan for and Create Short-Term Wins: Find quick, visible successes that can be celebrated. This provides motivation and evidence that the change is working.
7. Consolidate Improvements and Produce More Change: Use the credibility gained from short-term wins to tackle bigger, more challenging changes. Don't declare victory too soon!
8. Anchor New Approaches in the Culture: Ensure the new behaviours and strategies become embedded in the company culture. Make sure successors and new hires follow the new methods (similar to Lewin's 'Refreeze').

5. The Role of Leadership and Stakeholders in Managing Change

The success of any strategic change hinges on effective leadership and communication with stakeholders.

Leadership Style

Different situations require different leadership styles. During change, transformational leadership is often most effective.

• Transformational Leadership: Focuses on inspiring employees, communicating the vision, and encouraging followers to achieve goals they didn't think possible. This style is ideal for encouraging employees to embrace change and new ideas.
• Transactional Leadership: Focuses on supervision, organisation, and performance measured by rewards and punishments (transactions). This is less effective during periods of radical change as it tends to maintain the status quo rather than inspiring new ways of working.

The leader must be the primary champion for the change, demonstrating commitment and resilience.

Dealing with Stakeholder Concerns

A strategy for change must involve techniques to manage stakeholder resistance. The approach chosen depends on the time available and the power of the resisting group.

1. Education and Communication

Technique: Clearly explaining the rationale, the implications, and the benefits of the change. This is effective when resistance is based on misunderstanding.

2. Participation and Involvement

Technique: Allowing employees to contribute to the design and implementation of the change. They are more likely to commit if they feel ownership. This works well when employees have valuable information.

3. Facilitation and Support

Technique: Providing training, counselling, and time off to help employees adjust to new roles. This is effective when resistance is based on fear or anxiety (fear of the unknown).

4. Negotiation and Agreement

Technique: Offering incentives (like higher pay, better retirement benefits) in exchange for cooperation. This is useful when dealing with powerful stakeholders, such as trade unions.

5. Manipulation and Co-option

Technique: Giving a resisting individual a desirable role in the change process simply to gain their endorsement (co-option) or selectively presenting facts (manipulation). Warning: This approach can backfire badly if stakeholders realise they were tricked.

6. Explicit and Implicit Coercion

Technique: Threatening job loss or delayed promotions if the change is not accepted. This is a quick fix, used only as a last resort when speed is essential and the leader has significant power. Warning: This destroys trust and morale.

Final Key Takeaway: Effective change management—using models like Kotter’s or Lewin’s and employing appropriate communication and support strategies—is what turns strategic plans into successful business realities.