World religions - SL | Religious experience

Welcome to the Core of Faith: Understanding Religious Experience

Hello IB World Religions students! This chapter is incredibly important because it explores the "fuel" that drives religious belief and practice: Religious Experience (RE). While rituals and texts give us the structure of religion, religious experiences provide the direct, powerful connection to the divine or ultimate reality that validates everything else.

Since "Religious Experience" is a mandatory theme for your in-depth studies (Part 2), understanding this concept allows you to analyze how key doctrines and ethical systems in religions like Judaism, Christianity, or Buddhism were actually formed and sustained. Don't worry if this seems tricky at first—we'll break down these powerful moments into clear, manageable concepts!

Why is Religious Experience Important?

• It validates Doctrines/Beliefs: If a founder had a direct experience, the teachings based on that experience are seen as authoritative.
• It is the source of many Sacred Texts (e.g., prophetic revelations).
• It offers personal meaning and strengthens the commitment of Individual Believers.

1. Defining Religious Experience: What Is It Really?

In simple terms, a Religious Experience (RE) is a subjective feeling, awareness, or event that the person experiencing it interprets as involving contact with the divine, a higher power, or ultimate reality.

Key Characteristics of Religious Experience

When studying RE, religious scholars often look for these common features:

1. Subjectivity and Interiority:

• RE is primarily an internal, personal, and emotional event.
• Example: A person feeling an overwhelming sense of peace and forgiveness during prayer.

2. Transcendent Reality:

• The experience involves something beyond the normal physical world—the Ultimate Reality, God, Nirvana, etc.

3. Ineffability:

• The experience is often impossible to fully describe or express in ordinary language. It goes beyond words.
• Analogy: Try describing the colour red to someone born blind—it's impossible because they lack the frame of reference.

4. Noetic Quality:

• The experiencer gains deep, profound knowledge or insight that feels revealed or given by the divine. This knowledge is usually related to the nature of existence or reality.

Quick Takeaway: RE is a powerful, personal encounter with the sacred that often defies description but profoundly changes the person’s understanding of the world.

2. Categories of Religious Experience

To analyze RE effectively in your exams, you need a framework. Scholars often categorize experiences based on their effect or nature.

A. The Numinous Experience (The Holy Other)

This concept was popularized by philosopher Rudolf Otto, who defined the Numinous as the experience of the "mysterium tremendum et fascinans" (a mystery that is terrifying yet fascinating).

• Tremendum (Awe and Dread): It involves feelings of overwhelming power, majesty, and unapproachability—a sense of one's own insignificance before the sacred.
• Fascinans (Attraction and Mercy): Despite the dread, there is an overpowering attraction, comfort, and sense of bliss.

Did You Know? Many accounts of prophetic revelation—like Moses encountering the burning bush (Judaism/Christianity) or Muhammad receiving the Qur'an (Islam)—fit the numinous model, emphasizing God's overwhelming power and absolute difference from humanity.

B. The Mystical Experience (Union with the Ultimate)

Unlike Numinous experiences, which emphasize the gap between humanity and the divine, Mystical experiences focus on the dissolution of the self and a sense of absolute unity.

• Unitive Experience: The sense of separateness disappears. The individual feels unified with the divine or ultimate reality.
• Timelessness and Spacelessness: The normal boundaries of time and space cease to matter during the experience.
• Internal Focus: Mystical experiences are often achieved through intense meditation, contemplation, or ascetic practices (common in Eastern traditions like Hinduism and Buddhism).

Analogy: Imagine a drop of water that realizes it is part of the vast ocean, losing its individual identity but gaining the power of the whole ocean.

Examples of Mystical Goal States:

• Hinduism: The realization of Atman (self) being Brahman (Ultimate Reality), leading to Moksha (liberation).
• Buddhism: Achieving Nirvana or a sudden awakening (Satori or Kenshō in Zen).

C. Conversion Experiences

These experiences involve a fundamental and permanent shift in a person's life, beliefs, and moral conduct, often happening suddenly and dramatically.

• Intellectual Conversion: A shift in how a person understands and accepts the doctrines of a faith.
• Moral/Life Conversion: A radical change in behaviour and ethical outlook (e.g., moving from a life of vice to a life of pious observance).

Example: The conversion of Saul to Paul in Christianity, which was a sudden, dramatic event involving a vision and a blinding light, changing him from a persecutor to a dedicated apostle.

3. The Impact of Religious Experience in the Chosen Religions

When analyzing your two in-depth religions (e.g., Islam and Christianity), you must analyze how religious experiences shape their core themes.

A. Source of Authority and Sacred Texts

In many religions, the most important texts exist because of a foundational religious experience.

• Islam: The Qur'an is the direct, verbal revelation (wahy) received by Prophet Muhammad during a series of intense, numinous experiences, culminating in the Night of Power (Laylat al-Qadr). This experience is the primary basis for the authority of Islamic doctrine.
• Sikhism: Guru Nanak Dev's direct, mystical encounter with God near the River Bain is the foundational experience that led to the creation of the Mul Mantar and the start of the Sikh path.

B. Validation of Doctrines and Ethics

RE often serves to confirm or validate core beliefs that would otherwise be purely abstract.

• Christianity: The experiences of the apostles after the Resurrection and the descent of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost are religious experiences that validate the central doctrine of Christ’s divinity and the power of the Holy Spirit. These experiences motivated the earliest Christian community and shaped their ethics (caring for the poor, evangelism).
• Judaism: Moses’s encounters with God on Mount Sinai (Numinous experiences) not only delivered the Law but reaffirmed the covenant, establishing the ethical and legal framework (the Mitzvot) for the community.

C. Ongoing Spiritual Life and Practice

RE is not just historical; it is often the goal of current religious practices (Rituals).

• Hinduism (Bhakti Yoga): Devotional practices aim to achieve Darshan—the experience of seeing and being seen by the deity, often felt intensely during temple worship or rituals.
• Buddhism (Meditation): Practices like Vipassana (insight meditation) are designed to strip away illusions and lead the practitioner toward the immediate, felt experience of impermanence (anicca) and non-self (anatta), which are necessary steps toward Nirvana.

Common Mistake to Avoid:

Do not confuse a Ritual with a Religious Experience. A ritual (like baptism or Hajj) is the *structured action* designed to connect the believer to the divine. A religious experience is the *subjective, internal feeling* or awareness that may happen *during* or *as a result* of the ritual, or spontaneously.

***

Quick Review: Linking Religious Experience to the IB Themes

The ability to analyze how RE affects the other themes is crucial for Paper 2 essays:

RE + Sacred Texts: RE often dictates the content and authority of scriptures (e.g., Revelation of the Qur'an).

RE + Doctrines/Beliefs: RE validates and confirms central teachings (e.g., the Resurrection validates Christ’s identity).

RE + Ethics/Moral Conduct: RE can cause conversions, leading to fundamental changes in behavior and commitment to the religion’s moral code (e.g., Paul’s subsequent missionary work).

RE + Rituals: Rituals are the formalized ways that believers try to evoke or recreate significant religious experiences (e.g., meditation seeks to evoke mystical insight).