Economics (9640) | Monopolistic competition

👋 Welcome to Monopolistic Competition Notes!

Hi there! This chapter is incredibly important because it describes the market structure you see most often in the real world: the café down the street, your favourite local clothes shop, or even different brands of toothpaste.

Monopolistic Competition is where firms have features of both Monopoly (they have a little bit of control over their price) and Perfect Competition (many firms and easy entry).

Don't worry if this sounds complicated—we will break it down step-by-step, focusing especially on the diagrams and why this market structure delivers massive amounts of consumer choice!

Key Takeaway from the Introduction:

Monopolistic competition is the middle ground between the extreme structures of Perfect Competition and Pure Monopoly. Its main feature is product differentiation.

---

1. Characteristics of Monopolistically Competitive Markets

To classify a market as monopolistically competitive, it must exhibit four main characteristics (Syllabus 3.3.3.3):

1.1 Many Buyers and Sellers (Atomistic Market)

There are a large number of firms in the industry, and each firm is relatively small compared to the overall market size. This means that the actions of one firm (like changing its price) will have very little effect on its competitors.

• Analogy: Think of the fast-food industry in a large city. There are thousands of small takeaways and restaurants.

1.2 Product Differentiation (The Defining Feature)

This is the key characteristic! While the firms are selling similar products, the products are perceived as being different from one another. This allows firms to be price makers (unlike Perfect Competition where they are price takers).

Product differentiation can be achieved through:

• Physical Differences: Different ingredients in a sandwich, different design of a smartphone case.
• Marketing and Branding: Advertising that creates a specific image or loyalty (e.g., premium coffee vs. budget coffee).
• Location: A bakery right next to a train station is differentiated by convenience.
• Service: Excellent customer service or generous return policies.

1.3 Low Barriers to Entry and Exit (Freedom of Entry)

It is relatively easy for new firms to enter the market and for existing firms to leave. This is why supernormal profits are competed away in the long run.

• Did you know? Setting up a small online boutique or a local tutoring service usually requires very low start-up costs, resulting in low barriers to entry.

1.4 Price Makers (Facing a Downward-Sloping Demand Curve)

Because of product differentiation, a firm has a degree of monopoly power over its own product. If a local coffee shop slightly raises its price, it won't lose all its customers, because some customers are loyal to its unique blend or location.

• The firm's demand curve (which is also its Average Revenue curve, AR) is downward sloping.
• However, because there are many close substitutes, this demand curve is relatively elastic (flatter than a pure monopoly's curve).

---

2. Short-Run Equilibrium and Diagrammatic Analysis

The analysis in the short run is almost identical to that of a single-firm monopoly, because the firm is exploiting its unique position (differentiation).

2.1 The Profit Maximising Rule

Like all firms in standard economic theory, monopolistically competitive firms aim to maximise profits by producing at the output level where Marginal Cost (MC) equals Marginal Revenue (MR).

\[ \text{Profit Maximisation occurs where } MC = MR \]

2.2 Short-Run Profit Outcomes

In the short run, a monopolistically competitive firm can achieve three possible outcomes, depending on its average costs (AC) relative to its price (Average Revenue, AR):

1. Supernormal (Abnormal) Profit: This occurs if Price (AR) > Average Total Cost (AC).
2. Normal Profit: This occurs if Price (AR) = Average Total Cost (AC).
3. Short-Run Losses: This occurs if Price (AR) < Average Total Cost (AC).

2.3 Visualising Supernormal Profit (Short Run)

Imagine the firm "The Gourmet Burger Joint."

Step-by-Step Diagram Explanation (Required for Syllabus 3.3.3.3):

1. Draw a downward-sloping demand curve (AR) and a steeper downward-sloping Marginal Revenue curve (MR).
2. Draw the MC curve (U-shaped, cutting MR from below).
3. Find the profit maximising output \(Q_{SR}\) where \(MC = MR\).
4. Find the price \(P_{SR}\) by reading up from \(Q_{SR}\) to the AR curve.
5. Draw the Average Total Cost (AC) curve (U-shaped).
6. If the AC curve is below the price \(P_{SR}\) at the output \(Q_{SR}\), the firm is making supernormal profit. The profit area is the box defined by \((P_{SR} - AC) \times Q_{SR}\).

Key Takeaway: In the short run, the firm acts just like a monopoly, setting its price above its marginal cost and potentially earning significant profits due to its differentiated product.

---

3. Long-Run Equilibrium and Normal Profit

The real difference between Monopolistic Competition and Monopoly appears in the long run, due to the low barriers to entry.

3.1 The Process of Adjustment

If firms in the market are making supernormal profits in the short run, this attracts new firms to enter the industry.

1. New Entry: New firms enter, offering similar, differentiated products (e.g., if one burger joint is making huge profits, two new competing burger joints open nearby).
2. Increased Competition: The presence of more substitutes means the existing firm's individual demand curve (AR) becomes even more elastic (flatter), as consumers have more choice.
3. Demand Shifts Left: The demand curve (AR) for the existing firm shifts inwards (to the left), as customers are drawn away by the new competition.
4. Normal Profit: This process continues until the demand curve (AR) just touches the Average Total Cost (AC) curve.

3.2 Visualising Normal Profit (Long Run)

In the long run, firms earn only Normal Profit (Zero Economic Profit).

Step-by-Step Diagram Explanation (Required for Syllabus 3.3.3.3):

1. The long-run output \(Q_{LR}\) is still where \(MC = MR\).
2. The long-run price \(P_{LR}\) is read up to the AR curve.
3. The crucial point is the Tangency Condition: In the long run, the AR curve is tangent (just touches) the AC curve at output \(Q_{LR}\).
4. Because \(P_{LR} = AC\) at this output, the firm's Total Revenue equals its Total Cost, meaning it earns Normal Profit.

Important Point: A firm stays in the long run because normal profit includes opportunity cost—the return necessary to keep the entrepreneur in this specific business.

---

4. Non-Price Competition and Strengthening Monopoly Power

Since price competition leads to normal profits in the long run, firms in monopolistic competition focus heavily on non-price competition (Syllabus 3.3.3.3) to try and maintain some supernormal profit or increase consumer loyalty.

4.1 What is Non-Price Competition?

This involves methods other than reducing the price to increase sales and differentiate the product further.

• Advertising and Promotion: Creating brand loyalty (making demand less elastic).
• Improved Quality and Design: Continuously updating the product to stay ahead of rivals.
• Customer Service: Offering warranties, speedy delivery, or personalized sales advice.
• Branding and Packaging: Building a strong brand identity that consumers trust and are willing to pay a premium for.

4.2 The Role of Non-Price Competition

Non-price competition serves two main purposes:

1. Increase Demand: Effective advertising shifts the firm’s demand curve (AR) to the right.
2. Reduce Elasticity: Successful differentiation means consumers view the product as having fewer close substitutes, making their demand curve steeper (less elastic). If demand is less elastic, the firm can raise prices further away from MC without losing too many customers.

Syllabus Link: Non-price competition is a means by which firms strengthen their monopoly power but may also enhance the competitiveness of markets and benefit consumers.

---

5. Evaluation: Performance and Efficiency

When evaluating monopolistic competition, we compare its performance against the theoretical ideal of Perfect Competition (the efficiency benchmark).

5.1 Static Inefficiency in Monopolistic Competition

Monopolistic competition is generally considered statically inefficient in the long run.

1. Allocative Inefficiency (\(P > MC\)):

• Firms are price makers, so they set the price higher than the Marginal Cost of production.
• This means that consumers are paying more than the cost to society of producing the last unit. Resources are misallocated—society would benefit from more output being produced until \(P = MC\).

2. Productive Inefficiency (\(P > \text{Minimum AC}\)):

• In the long run, the firm produces an output \(Q_{LR}\) that is to the left of the lowest point on the Average Cost curve.
• This gap between the equilibrium output and the minimum efficient scale is called excess capacity. The firm is not producing at the lowest possible cost, so it is productively inefficient.

Common Mistake to Avoid: Don't confuse Allocative Inefficiency (P > MC) with Productive Inefficiency (not producing at the minimum of AC). They are two distinct points of failure.

5.2 Dynamic Efficiency and Consumer Benefits

Despite the static inefficiencies, monopolistic competition offers significant benefits that might lead to dynamic efficiency:

• Consumer Choice and Variety: Consumers value variety. Monopolistic competition provides a massive array of differentiated products (e.g., hundreds of different soft drinks or detergents). This non-price competition enhances welfare, even if the price is slightly higher than marginal cost.
• Innovation: The pressure of non-price competition forces firms to constantly improve their product, service, and design (dynamic efficiency). If a firm stops innovating, its demand curve will shift left as consumers switch to new, better products offered by rivals.

Conclusion on Performance: Although monopolistic competition is technically inefficient compared to Perfect Competition (due to P > MC and excess capacity), economists often argue that the cost of this inefficiency is a small price to pay for the great variety, choice, and incentive for innovation that the market structure provides to consumers.

---

Final Monopolistic Competition Summary

Monopolistic competition is a market structure defined by many firms, low barriers to entry, and crucial product differentiation.

• Short Run: Firms can make Supernormal Profit (P > AC).
• Long Run: New entry competes profits away, leading to Normal Profit (P = AC), marked by the AR curve being tangent to the AC curve.
• Efficiency: It suffers from static inefficiency (P > MC and excess capacity), but often provides compensating dynamic efficiency and high consumer choice due to non-price competition.