Business (9625) | Choosing strategic direction

Welcome to Choosing Strategic Direction!

Hello future business leaders! This chapter is all about making the big decisions—the ones that determine where your business will go and how it will beat the competition. Think of it as mapping out the route before a long journey. You've already analyzed your internal strengths (SWOT) and the external environment (PESTEL, Porter's Five Forces). Now, it's time to choose the path forward!

We will focus on two crucial tools: The Ansoff Matrix (What products and markets should we target?) and Bowman's Strategic Clock (How should we compete?).

Key Takeaway: Strategy vs. Tactics

Remember, we are discussing strategic decisions here, not tactical decisions. Strategic decisions are long-term, high-risk, and affect the whole business (e.g., deciding to enter a new continent). Tactical decisions are short-term and operational (e.g., deciding next month's pricing).

---

Section 1: Strategic Direction – The Ansoff Matrix

The Ansoff Matrix (sometimes called the Product/Market Matrix) is a fantastic tool developed by Igor Ansoff. It helps managers analyze and select strategies for future growth by considering the combination of products (existing or new) and markets (existing or new).

It’s easy to visualize as a 2x2 grid, helping you manage risk vs. reward.

Memory Aid: Think of Ansoff as asking: "Should we try something New or stick to what Exists, both with our products and our customers?"

1. Market Penetration (Existing Product, Existing Market)

   What is it?

   Selling more of your existing products to your existing customers. The goal is to increase market share.

   How do we do it?

   Lowering prices, increasing promotion (more advertising), increasing distribution efforts, or encouraging repeat purchases.

   Value and Risk:

   This is generally the lowest risk strategy because you know your product and you know your customers. However, growth potential is limited, especially in saturated markets.

   Example: Coca-Cola constantly running ads and promotional offers in countries where it is already sold widely.



2. Product Development (New Product, Existing Market)

   What is it?

   Creating new products (or significantly improved ones) to sell to your current customer base.

   How do we do it?

   Heavy investment in Research & Development (R&D), focusing on innovation and quality.

   Value and Risk:

   Moderate risk. You understand the market and customer needs, but developing a new product is expensive and carries the risk of failure (launching a 'flop').

   Example: Apple releasing a new version of the iPhone or a new feature like the Apple Watch, targeted at existing Apple users.



3. Market Development (Existing Product, New Market)

   What is it?

   Taking existing products and selling them in new markets.

   How do we do it?

   Exporting internationally, targeting a new demographic (e.g., selling adult products to teenagers), or finding a new use for the product.

   Value and Risk:

   Moderate risk. The product is proven, but the new market may have cultural differences, intense competition, or require massive adjustments to distribution.

   Example: A successful local restaurant chain deciding to open its first location in a different city or country.



4. Diversification (New Product, New Market)

   What is it?

   Moving into completely new markets with completely new products. This is often done to spread risk or capitalize on high-growth sectors.

   How do we do it?

   This usually requires mergers, takeovers, or significant internal structural change.

   Value and Risk:

   This is the highest risk strategy because the business is operating in unknown territory on two fronts. If successful, however, the rewards can be massive.

   Example: A fashion retailer deciding to start running a chain of hotels. They have no experience in the hotel market or running that type of operation.

Choosing a Strategic Direction: The Factors

The choice depends on several factors:

• Risk Appetite: Is the business conservative (prefers Market Penetration) or aggressive (willing to attempt Diversification)?
• Market Conditions: Is the existing market saturated? If yes, penetration won't work, and development/diversification is needed.
• Available Resources: Diversification and Product Development require massive R&D and capital investment.
• Competitive Environment: Are there high barriers to entry in the new market?

---

Section 2: Strategic Positioning – Bowman's Strategic Clock

Once a business decides *where* it wants to compete (using Ansoff), it needs to decide *how* it will compete. This is called strategic positioning.

Bowman’s Strategic Clock is a tool used to analyze the competitive position of a business based on two key dimensions:

1. Price (What the customer pays)
2. Perceived Value/Benefits (What the customer believes they are getting for that price)

The clock identifies eight different strategic positions, but we focus on the successful routes (1-5) and the failure zones (6-8).

1. Position 1: Low Price / Low Value (No Frills)

   The product is basic, and the price is the lowest possible. Customers are very price-sensitive. Example: Cheap budget airlines or generic supermarket products.

2. Position 2: Low Price (Economy)

   Products are still low priced, but the perceived value is slightly higher than Position 1. This strategy is only sustainable if the business has a huge cost advantage (e.g., massive economies of scale). Example: Walmart or discount retailers.

3. Position 3: Hybrid (Moderate Price / Moderate Differentiation)

   The product offers a good balance of reasonable price and reasonable features. This is a very common strategy for mid-range brands.

4. Position 4: Differentiation

   The product has high perceived value (due to branding, quality, or features) but is sold at a medium price. The goal is to justify the price through quality. Example: Brands like Nike or Samsung (non-premium range).

5. Position 5: Focused Differentiation (Luxury/Premium)

   The product offers the highest perceived value and is sold at a premium price. The customer believes the high cost is worth the exclusivity, quality, or status. Example: Rolex watches, Ferrari cars, or high-end designer clothing.

The Failure Zones (Positions 6, 7, and 8)

These positions are generally unsustainable and lead to failure:

• Position 6: High Price / Low Value: Charging a high price for a basic product. Customers will quickly switch once they realize the lack of value.
• Position 7: Monopoly Pricing: Only possible if you have absolutely no competitors (a true monopoly). If competitors appear, this position instantly fails.
• Position 8: Low Value / Standard Price: If your product offers low perceived benefits but costs the same as competitors who offer more, you will lose market share rapidly. This is known as loss of market share.

Influences on Choosing a Strategy

What influences where a business places itself on the clock?

• Cost Structure: If costs are high, you cannot compete in Position 1 or 2.
• Target Market: Are your customers primarily seeking low cost or high quality?
• Competitors: If the market is flooded with low-price competitors, trying to enter Position 1 might lead to a destructive price war.
• Product Nature: It’s hard to sell complex machinery using a "no frills" strategy (Position 1).

---

Section 3: Competitive Advantage

The whole point of choosing a strategic direction (Ansoff) and a competitive position (Bowman) is to gain a competitive advantage.

What is Competitive Advantage?

A competitive advantage (CA) is a feature or characteristic of a business that allows it to generate more sales, attract more customers, or sustain higher profit margins than its rivals.

A CA must be sustainable—meaning competitors find it very difficult or expensive to copy.

How is Competitive Advantage achieved?

Generally, CA is achieved in one of two ways (linking directly to Bowman’s Clock):

1. Cost Leadership: Achieving the lowest production costs in the industry (allowing Position 1 or 2 on the clock). This is usually achieved through massive economies of scale or access to cheaper resources.
2. Differentiation: Offering a unique, high-quality product that customers are willing to pay a premium for (allowing Position 4 or 5 on the clock). This is achieved through branding, R&D, or superior customer service.

Benefits of Having a Competitive Advantage

• Higher Profit Margins: If you are the cost leader, your profit margin per unit is higher. If you are differentiated, you can charge a higher price.
• Increased Market Share: Customers are drawn to the superior value proposition (whether that's superior low cost or superior quality).
• Barriers to Entry: A strong CA (like a powerful brand or patented technology) makes it difficult for new rivals to enter the market.
• Customer Loyalty: Strong differentiation often creates loyal customers who are less likely to switch when a rival drops their price slightly.

Difficulties of Maintaining a Competitive Advantage

Don't worry if this seems tricky—no CA lasts forever! Maintaining it is often harder than achieving it initially.

1. Competitor Response: Rivals will inevitably try to copy your strategy. If you lower costs, they will try to find cheaper suppliers. If you innovate, they will reverse-engineer your product.
2. Dynamic Markets: Consumer tastes change quickly. A differentiated product today might be standard tomorrow (e.g., touch-screen phones were differentiated ten years ago, now they are standard).
3. Innovation Costs: Maintaining differentiation requires continuous R&D spending and investment, which puts pressure on costs.
4. Resource Scarcity: If your cost advantage relies on exclusive access to a cheap resource or technology, that resource may become scarce or accessible to competitors over time.