Accounting (9615) | Interpretation, analysis and communication of accounting information

📈 Interpretation, Analysis and Communication of Accounting Information (A-Level Focus)

Hey there, future financial analyst! Welcome to one of the most crucial chapters in A-Level Accounting. You've spent a lot of time learning *how* to prepare financial statements; now, we learn the essential skill of turning those numbers into powerful stories and meaningful decisions. This is where Accounting truly connects to the real world!

The goal isn't just calculation—it’s about providing informed judgements and recommendations to stakeholders, considering both financial and non-financial factors.

Part 1: Deeper Financial Analysis – Moving Beyond AS Ratios

You already know the core ratios (Gross Profit Margin, Current Ratio, Inventory Turnover). At A-Level, we use these alongside more advanced metrics to get a comprehensive view of the business's health (Profitability, Liquidity, Efficiency, and Capital Structure).

Performance Appraisal Focus Areas

When assessing a business, your analysis must focus on four key areas:

• Profitability: How well is the business generating profit relative to its revenue and the capital invested? (e.g., Return on Capital Employed (ROCE)).
• Liquidity: Can the business meet its short-term debts? (e.g., Current Ratio, Liquid Capital Ratio).
• Efficiency (or Activity): How effectively is the business managing its assets and operations? (e.g., Inventory Turnover, Trade Receivable Days).
• Capital Structure (or Solvency): How the business is financed (debt vs. equity) and its ability to meet long-term obligations. (e.g., Capital Gearing).

Advanced Investor Ratios (For Shareholders)

These ratios are critical for potential and current shareholders who need to evaluate the return and risk of their investment.

1. Earnings Per Share (EPS): The portion of a company's profit allocated to each individual ordinary share.
   A higher EPS usually indicates higher profitability for shareholders.
2. Price Earnings (P/E) Ratio: Compares the current market price of the share to its EPS.

The P/E ratio shows how many times earnings investors are willing to pay for a share. A high P/E ratio suggests investors expect high future growth.

3. Dividend Yield: Shows the cash return to shareholders as a percentage of the market price.

Formula Example: \(\text{Dividend Yield} = \frac{\text{Dividend Per Share}}{\text{Market Price Per Share}} \times 100\%\)

4. Dividend Cover: Measures how many times the company’s profit can cover the dividend paid out.

A high cover ratio suggests the dividend is safe and the company retains funds for growth. A low cover ratio suggests the company is paying out nearly all its profits, which might be unsustainable.

5. Interest Cover: Measures the company's ability to meet its interest payments from its operating profit.

A high interest cover (e.g., 5 or 6 times) assures lenders that the business can comfortably pay its debt interest. Low interest cover suggests a high risk of default.

---

---

The Crucial Distinction: Cash vs. Profit

It is vital to understand that a profitable business can still run out of cash (and vice versa).

• Profit: Calculated in the Income Statement (P&L). It includes non-cash items like depreciation and only recognises sales/expenses when they occur (accruals concept), not when cash changes hands.
• Cash: Calculated in the Statement of Cash Flows. It reflects the physical movement of money in and out of the bank.

Example: You sell goods on credit for $10,000. Your profit increases immediately by $10,000. However, if the customer doesn't pay you for 60 days, your cash balance remains unchanged for those 60 days. This transaction increases profitability but does not immediately increase liquidity.

Key Takeaway (Part 1): A-Level analysis demands you look beyond basic profit ratios and assess investor returns and solvency (gearing), always remembering that cash flow (liquidity) is separate from accounting profit.

Part 2: Limitations of Financial Statements and Ratios

Don't worry if the numbers don't paint a perfect picture! Accounting is an art, not just a science. To provide sound judgements, you must recognise the limitations of the data.

1. Financial Limitations

These relate to the nature of the data itself:

• Historic Cost: Assets are recorded at their original purchase price. This figure might be totally irrelevant in today’s market, especially for old property, making comparisons difficult.
• Accounting Policies: Different businesses use different methods (e.g., different depreciation rates or inventory valuation methods), making direct comparison difficult.
• Window Dressing: Management might manipulate figures at year-end (e.g., delaying payments or boosting sales just before the reporting date) to make the financial position look better than it truly is.
• Inflation: Comparing figures across many years (time series analysis) can be misleading if the purchasing power of money has changed significantly.

2. Non-Financial Limitations

These crucial factors are not captured by the financial statements but heavily influence performance:

• Economic Climate: Was the increase in sales due to great management or simply a booming economy?
• Management Quality: Are the managers skilled, innovative, and experienced?
• Market Conditions: Does the company face strong competition? Is their product line becoming obsolete?
• Customer Satisfaction/Reputation: Poor customer service won't immediately show up as a low ratio but will destroy long-term profits.
• Environmental/Social Impact: A company might be highly profitable but violate environmental laws, posing a massive future risk.

Evaluating Performance (Internal and External)

To overcome these limitations, performance must be evaluated using three methods:

1. Internal Comparison (Time Series): Comparing the current period's results with previous periods (e.g., 2024 vs. 2023). This helps identify trends.
2. Against Budgets: Comparing actual performance to the planned targets (Management Accounting).
3. External Comparison (Benchmarking): Comparing the company’s ratios to industry averages or key competitors. (Warning: Only compare companies in the same industry using similar methods!)

Key Takeaway (Part 2): Ratios provide clues, not absolute answers. Your analysis must integrate these financial clues with the context of the business’s environment and management quality to form a proper judgement.

Part 3: Communication and Stakeholders

Who cares about your analysis? Everyone! Effective communication means tailoring the information to meet the specific needs and interests of different groups.

Identifying Stakeholders and Their Interests

Stakeholders are anyone with an interest in the business's performance.

A. Internal Stakeholders:

• Owners/Shareholders: Interested in profitability (EPS, dividends) and the security/growth of their investment (P/E ratio, capital structure).
• Management: Need detailed, timely information (often using management accounting budgets and variances) to plan, control, and make day-to-day decisions.
• Employees: Concerned about job security, pay increases, and the company's long-term sustainability (profitability, liquidity).

B. External Stakeholders:

• Lenders (Banks): Primarily interested in solvency and liquidity (Interest Cover, Gearing, Current Ratio) to ensure loans will be repaid.
• Suppliers (Trade Payables): Interested in short-term liquidity (Current Ratio, Trade Payable Days) to ensure they will be paid for goods supplied on credit.
• Customers: Interested in the firm's stability and survival, especially if they rely on the firm for long-term supplies or maintenance.
• Government/Tax Authorities: Concerned with compliance, calculating tax owed, and gathering economic statistics.
• Local Community: Interested in job creation, corporate social responsibility (CSR), and environmental impact.

The Value of Published Accounts

Publicly available financial statements are the main source of information for external stakeholders (excluding the government, who may demand more detail). They provide a standard, regulated basis for comparison, ensuring transparency and reducing information asymmetry.

Recording Systems: Computerised vs. Manual

The system used to record data impacts the speed, accuracy, and accessibility of the information used for analysis:

Computerised Systems	Manual Systems
Advantages: Speed, automated calculations, instant reports, reduced human error, easier storage.	Advantages: Low initial cost, easy to understand for small businesses, less vulnerable to cyber threats.
Disadvantages: High setup cost, reliance on IT expertise, risk of data loss or security breaches.	Disadvantages: Time-consuming, high risk of calculation errors, difficult to generate complex reports quickly.

Did you know? Even the largest companies started with manual systems. The transition to computerised systems became necessary as transaction volume increased, making manual ledger entries impractical and prone to error.

Key Takeaway (Part 3): Communication requires customisation. When making a recommendation, always explain its impact on various stakeholders (e.g., "Raising a loan will increase gearing, which satisfies the owners seeking expansion but increases risk for lenders and may worry employees").

Part 4: The Impact of Ethical Considerations (3.2.10)

The integrity of accounting information hinges entirely on the ethical behaviour of the accountant. Your judgements and recommendations must be sound and unbiased.

The Five Fundamental Ethical Principles

Professional accountants, regardless of their sector (business or public practice), must adhere to these five principles:

1. Integrity: To be straightforward and honest in all professional and business relationships. (You must not knowingly be associated with misleading information.)
2. Objectivity: To not allow bias, conflict of interest, or undue influence of others to override professional or business judgments. (Your analysis must be fair, even if the results are bad for your employer.)
3. Professional Competence and Due Care: To maintain professional knowledge and skill at the level required to ensure that clients/employers receive competent professional service. (This means staying updated on IAS/IFRS standards and tax laws.)
4. Confidentiality: To respect the confidentiality of information acquired as a result of professional and business relationships. (You cannot share client sales figures with a competitor.)
5. Professional Behaviour: To comply with relevant laws and regulations and avoid any action that discredits the profession. (This relates to conduct in the workplace and public perception.)

Impacts of Ethical Behaviour

These principles influence the entire business environment:

• Accountant in Business: Must ensure financial reports are transparent, even if pressure exists from management to manipulate profit.
• Auditors and Audit Report: Auditors rely heavily on objectivity and integrity to provide an independent and true/fair view of the statements.
• Corporate Governance: Ethical principles underpin good governance, ensuring the board of directors acts in the best interest of shareholders and stakeholders.
• Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR): A company acting ethically will consider its social and environmental footprint beyond minimum legal requirements.

Don't worry if this seems tricky at first! Applying ethics is about common sense and courage. If you feel pressure to record something incorrectly, that's usually a breach of Integrity and Objectivity.

Dealing with Ethical Conflicts (What to do?)

If you suspect an unethical or illegal act, you should follow these steps (in order):

1. Apply Codes of Practice: Consult the code of conduct provided by your professional body (e.g., ACCA, ICAEW).
2. Ensure Safeguards: Discuss the issue internally, perhaps with a superior, non-involved manager, or the audit committee.
3. Evaluate Significance of Threats: Assess how severe the breach of the fundamental principles is.
4. Resolve Conflict: If internal safeguards fail, seek external/professional help (e.g., legal counsel or the professional body itself).

Key Takeaway (Part 4): Calculations are useless if they are not Integrity checked. Ethical behaviour is fundamental to maintaining trust in financial reporting, which is essential for the function of the capital market.