Regulatory and Ethical Considerations (A Level Topic 3.2)
Hey Accounting Superstars!
Welcome to one of the most important conceptual sections in your A-Level syllabus. You might be brilliant at calculating ratios and preparing statements, but without the rules and ethics we are about to cover, those numbers are useless!
This chapter focuses on the regulatory framework (the rules we must follow) and the ethical framework (the moral standards we must uphold). These ensure that financial information is reliable, comparable, and trustworthy for everyone who uses it.
Quick Review Box: Why Do We Need Rules?
- To ensure consistency (all companies follow the same format).
- To allow comparability (so investors can compare Company A and Company B).
- To promote credibility and trust in financial statements.
Section 1: The Regulatory Framework – International Accounting Standards (IAS)
The global accounting world is governed by rules, known as International Accounting Standards (IAS) or International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). You need to understand the main purpose of specific IAS rules that affect how certain items are shown in the financial statements.
Don't worry about memorizing every tiny detail of these standards—focus on the core principle each one addresses!
Specific IAS Provisions You Must Know
IAS 1: Presentation of Financial Statements
Main Provision: This is the foundation. It sets out the required format, structure, and minimum content for a company's financial statements (e.g., Statement of Financial Position, Statement of Profit or Loss). It ensures statements are presented clearly and consistently.
Analogy: IAS 1 is like the standard recipe book for preparing accounts; it dictates what ingredients (elements) go where.
IAS 2: Inventories
Main Provision: Dictates how inventory (stock) must be valued. It states that inventory must be valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value (NRV).
Concept Check: NRV is the estimated selling price minus any estimated costs of completion or sale. This application links directly back to the accounting concept of prudence.
IAS 7: Statement of Cash Flows
Main Provision: Requires the presentation of a Statement of Cash Flows (SCF), categorizing cash movements into three main activities: Operating, Investing, and Financing.
Why is this important? It shows the business's ability to generate cash and manage its liquidity, which profit/loss figures alone cannot fully reveal.
IAS 8: Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors
Main Provision: Sets the rules for selecting and applying accounting policies. It also governs how to deal with corrections of material errors from prior periods, ensuring these changes are applied retrospectively (as if the new policy or correction had always been in place) to maintain comparability.
IAS 10: Events After the Reporting Period
Main Provision: Deals with events that occur between the reporting date (e.g., 31 December) and the date the statements are authorized for issue. Events must be classified as adjusting (requiring changes to figures) or non-adjusting (requiring disclosure only).
Example: If a major trade receivable went bankrupt *after* the year end, but before the reports were published, and the cause of bankruptcy existed at the year end, this is an adjusting event.
IAS 16: Property, Plant and Equipment (PPE)
Main Provision: Governs how tangible non-current assets (land, buildings, machinery) are initially recognized, measured (at cost or revaluation model), and subsequently depreciated. It sets rules on component depreciation and recognition of capital expenditure.
IAS 36: Impairment of Assets
Main Provision: Requires a business to test non-current assets periodically to ensure they are not stated at a value higher than their recoverable amount. If the asset's carrying amount (book value) is higher than the recoverable amount, the asset is considered impaired, and the loss must be recorded.
Simply put: This standard stops companies from overstating the value of assets that are no longer productive or needed.
IAS 37: Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets
Main Provision: Provides criteria for when a provision (liability of uncertain timing or amount, e.g., warranty costs) should be recognized, ensuring that only present obligations are included. It distinguishes provisions from contingent liabilities (possible obligations which are only disclosed in notes).
Did you know? Companies can’t just set aside money for a potential bad year; the provision must relate to an existing event or legal obligation.
IAS 38: Intangible Assets
Main Provision: Specifies the accounting treatment for non-monetary assets without physical substance, such as patents, copyrights, and capitalised development costs. Importantly, inherent goodwill (goodwill generated internally) is not recognized as an asset, but purchased goodwill is.
***
KEY TAKEAWAY (Regulatory): The IAS/IFRS framework exists to standardize the look and content of financial statements globally, increasing accountability and ensuring adherence to the conceptual framework (like prudence and matching).
***
Section 2: Ethical Considerations in Accounting
It’s not enough to follow the rules (IAS); accountants and businesses must also operate with integrity. Ethics are the moral principles that govern a person's behaviour.
The Need for an Ethical Framework
Accountants hold powerful positions. They control sensitive financial data, they advise managers, and they prepare reports that millions of people (investors, banks, employees) rely on to make major decisions. Without a strong ethical framework, there is a massive risk of fraud and manipulation, leading to lack of public trust.
The Fundamental Principles of Professional Ethics
Professional bodies (like ACCA or ICAEW) define five core principles that all accountants must uphold. These are vital for maintaining the reputation of the profession.
Memory Aid: I Often Prepare Confidential Papers (to remember the first letter of each principle!)
- Integrity:
This means being straightforward, honest, and truthful in all professional and business relationships. Accountants must not be associated with information that contains false or misleading statements.
Example: An accountant refuses to hide an expense as a non-current asset, even if the manager asks them to, because that would be dishonest.
- Objectivity:
This principle requires that accountants do not allow bias, conflict of interest, or undue influence of others to override professional or business judgements. Their work must be impartial.
Example: An auditor must refuse to audit a company where their spouse holds a senior management position, as this creates a conflict of interest.
- Professional Competence and Due Care:
Accountants must maintain their knowledge and skills at the level required to ensure that clients or employers receive competent professional service. Due Care means acting diligently and applying technical and professional standards when preparing reports.
Example: Regularly attending training courses to stay updated on the latest IAS standards.
- Confidentiality:
Accountants must respect the confidentiality of information acquired as a result of professional and business relationships and should not disclose any such information to third parties without proper and specific authority (unless there is a legal duty to disclose).
Example: An accountant cannot share confidential product development costs with a competitor.
- Professional Behaviour:
Accountants must comply with relevant laws and regulations and must avoid any action that discredits the profession.
Example: Avoiding any illegal activity or aggressive tax avoidance schemes that bring the accounting firm's reputation into question.
The Impact of Ethical Behaviour
The ethical behaviour of accountants and auditors impacts various stakeholders:
- Investors/Lenders: Ethical conduct ensures financial reports are reliable, leading to sound investment decisions. Unethical behaviour (e.g., inflated profits) leads to losses when the truth is revealed.
- Employees: Ethical decisions regarding restructuring, expenses, and asset valuation affect job security and bonuses.
- The Public/Government: Honest reporting ensures correct taxes are paid and prevents major corporate collapses that can harm the economy (like the Enron scandal).
The Social Implications of Decision-Making
Business decisions often have effects that go beyond profit and loss. Accountants must consider these broader impacts (the social implications):
- Environmental Costs: Should a company choose a cheaper production method that pollutes more, or a more expensive, sustainable method?
- Community Impact: If the company closes a factory to save costs, how many people in that town lose their jobs?
- Fairness: Are suppliers being paid on time? Are wages fair?
Even though the primary purpose of financial accounting is profit, ethical accountants recognize that short-term cost savings can lead to long-term reputational damage or harm to society.
***
KEY TAKEAWAY (Ethics): The five fundamental principles (Integrity, Objectivity, Professional Competence, Confidentiality, Professional Behaviour) are essential. Accountants must apply these principles when presenting a true and fair view of the company’s affairs.
***
Section 3: Auditing and Stewardship of Limited Companies
When a business becomes a limited company, the link between ownership and control changes. This introduces the concept of stewardship and the mandatory requirement for an independent audit.
Stewardship and Director Responsibilities
In a limited company:
- The owners are the shareholders.
- The managers are the directors.
The directors act as stewards. They are entrusted with managing the company's assets and resources on behalf of the shareholders. Their core responsibility is to account for these resources truthfully and efficiently.
The Importance of a True and Fair View
The primary aim of financial statements is to show a true and fair view (or presentation) of the company's financial position and performance.
- True: The accounts are factually correct, comply with IAS, and are free from material errors.
- Fair: The accounts are unbiased, objective, and reflect the commercial reality of the transactions, rather than just the legal form (substance over form).
The Role and Responsibilities of the Auditor
Because shareholders rarely manage the company themselves, they need an independent party—the auditor—to check the directors' work.
The auditor's main role is to provide an opinion on whether the financial statements show a true and fair view and comply with relevant regulations.
Key Responsibilities of the Auditor:
- Examining accounting records and systems.
- Checking that the statements adhere to IAS/IFRS.
- Reporting their findings to the shareholders.
External Audit vs. Internal Audit
Don't confuse these two roles:
External Audit:
- Purpose: Statutory (required by law for limited companies).
- Who: Independent auditing firm (external to the company).
- Focus: Verifying the financial statements show a true and fair view.
- Recipient: Shareholders (owners).
Internal Audit:
- Purpose: Non-statutory (optional, done internally by management).
- Who: Employees of the company.
- Focus: Reviewing and improving the effectiveness of internal controls, risk management, and operational efficiency.
- Recipient: Directors and management.
Qualified vs. Unqualified Audit Report
The auditor communicates their opinion through the Audit Report. The type of report matters greatly to stakeholders:
1. Unqualified Audit Report (Clean Opinion):
- The statements are free from material misstatements and present a true and fair view.
- This is the best outcome; it gives stakeholders confidence.
2. Qualified Audit Report:
- The statements are generally acceptable, BUT there are specific material issues where the auditor disagrees with the company’s treatment or was unable to gather enough evidence.
- A qualified report acts as a warning sign to investors.
Common Mistake to Avoid: A qualified report does NOT mean the company committed fraud. It means the accountant did not follow IAS rules correctly in a material way, or the auditor couldn't verify a specific figure (scope limitation).
***
KEY TAKEAWAY (Auditing): Directors have stewardship duties toward shareholders. The external auditor provides an independent check on the financial statements, aiming to issue an unqualified report, confirming the accounts give a true and fair view.
***